| 1st | Unaffilated (J. Miros) [G/65/36.1] | 04:01.01 | | 00:36.10 |
| 2nd | Whitemarsh (P. Banginwar) [AA/24/0.0] | 04:02.10 | 0.5% | |
| 3rd | Wilmington (C. Graham) [H/71/48.4] | 04:04.51 | 1.5% | 00:48.40 |
| 4th | Nereid (E. King) [E/58/24.0] | 04:07.00 | 2.5% | 00:24.00 |
| 5th | Swan Creek (M. Craig) [G/67/40.0] | 04:10.22 | 3.8% | 00:40.00 |
| 6th | Passaic River (E. Abahurire) [A/31/0.4] | 04:17.75 | 6.9% | 00:00.40 |