| 1st | Vesper (K. Wobeser) [D/52/0.0] | 04:05.66 | | |
| 2nd | Saugatuck (W. Shaw) [G/69/28.5] | 04:06.46 | 0.3% | 00:28.50 |
| 3rd | Nereid (I. Hawkins) [F/60/11.6] | 04:09.72 | 1.7% | 00:11.60 |
| 4th | Fairmount (M. Hurley) [G/68/26.4] | 04:21.18 | 6.3% | 00:26.40 |
| 5th | Fairmount (S. Jonik) [H/71/32.8] | 04:21.44 | 6.4% | 00:32.80 |