| 1st | Saugatuck (S. Dodge) [E/59/21.0] | 04:08.13 | | 00:21.00 |
| 2nd | Wilmington (R. Rock-Blake) [B/39/2.0] | 04:21.38 | 5.3% | 00:02.00 |
| 3rd | Greenwich (D. Herman) [F/61/23.9] | 04:29.29 | 8.5% | 00:23.90 |
| 4th | Three Rivers (E. Kiehn) [A/34/0.0] | 04:33.00 | 10.0% | |
| 5th | Rutgers Alumni (E. Lynes) [D/54/14.6] | 04:48.19 | 16.1% | 00:14.60 |