| 1st | Whitemarsh (A. McBlane) [F/62/23.4] | 04:23.05 | | 00:23.40 |
| 2nd | Carnegie Lake (B. Hogan) [I/78/57.8] | 04:23.50 | 0.2% | 00:57.80 |
| 3rd | Saugatuck (K. Davis) [F/62/23.4] | 04:27.95 | 1.9% | 00:23.40 |
| 4th | Cortlandt (N. Woodard) [F/64/27.0] | 04:43.88 | 7.9% | 00:27.00 |
| 5th | Carnegie Lake (D. Lantz-Hecker) [F/63/25.2] | 04:48.38 | 9.6% | 00:25.20 |
| 6th | Carnegie Lake (K. Seymour) [C/44/0.0] | 04:59.50 | 13.9% | |